Film review: Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014)

“Captain America: The Winter Soldier” with Chris Evans, Samuel L. Jackson, Scarlett Johansson, Robert Redford, Sebastian Stan, Anthony Mackie, and Cobie Smulders

Directed by Anthony Russo, Joe Russo, Written by Christopher Markus (Screenplay), Stephen McFeely (Screenplay), Ed Brubaker (concept and story), Joe Simon (comic book), and Jack Kirby (comic book)

PosterThe Marvel Cinematic Universe, otherwise dubbed as “MCU,” continues to expand and impress with each new film introduced into the respective universe and the newest Captain America film, “Captain America: The Winter Soldier,” exceeds expectations more than ever.  Marvel Studios seems to now uncover pieces of a puzzle to us one at a time, letting audiences dive into the action and lore of the current generation.  Some pieces have several adjacent pieces already exposed in prior releases, while on other sides we have only film titles, future release dates, and a handful of factoids.  Regardless, the amount of cohesion that is the MCU puzzle is impressive and never before been done; Marvel Studios’ Kevin Feige have pioneered the film industry and what it means to be a franchise.

“Captain America: The Winter Soldier” fits into the puzzle so well, its quality is on par with or even exceeds Joss Whedon’s 2012, “The Avengers.”  Gone are the days of the cheesy Marvel films, audiences now get to enjoy comic book films that are deeply entrenched in nerdery but so well-crafted it is as-if we are watching the newest high-caliber thriller, espionage film akin to the likes of Ludlum’s Bourne or the grittiness of a Ridley Scott drama.  “Captain America: Winter Soldier” is no exception, and while uncovering a new piece of the Marvel puzzle to us, it also pulls from the rich genre well of the great conspiracy films from the 1970s— Bits and pieces elegantly placed together to create a modern retelling of some of the great genre films of the past.

If curious check out this great article by IGN’s Daniel Krupa, “5 Films You Should See After Captain America: Winter Soldier.”  Krupa details out specifics references of Winter Soldier’s obvious respect to cinema history and recommends some of the best espionage films of the era that “Captain America: Winter Soldier” most-likely pulls from.

05Picking up after the events of the first Captain America as well as “The Avengers,” the newest entry into the Marvel series places Captain Steve Rogers in a new world, specifically a new world order.  The inside jokes and technological marvels of the second modern millennium are not as confounding to the Captain as they were in “The Avengers (2012),” but he still lives as a man out of time.  He is conflicted, but at an ideological level.

He pulls upon the threads of a lost life by finding lovers and compatriots of the old.  However, more important than his lust for a forgotten time, he is torn between the ideologies of the time.  Forcing good and evil into a black and white spectrum, just doesn’t seem as easy as it was back in the day, and the idea of secrecy and espionage being the mainstay in a constant struggle tears at Captain America, which is essentially the driving force behind the film.

Captain America is in a brave new world and he knows nothing else than being a soldier.  He is at service to his country, and is trying to find his footing in a different type of war.  The film opens with Cap making a connection with a fellow soldier as they run laps around the mall in front of the Washington Monument.  This seemingly small connection expands throughout the film because it provides Cap a connection to the era; war is eternal and the two can relate even across the decades.

10Captain America’s newfound running mate is later introduced as Falcon (aka Sam Wilson) played by the talented Anthony Mackie.  Alongside Captain America and Falcon, Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson); Maria Hill (Cobie Smulders); and Nick Fury (Sam Jackson) round out the primary protagonists, subsequently pitting them against a villain from Cap’s past and present in a sweeping plot that will have long lasting consequences upon S.H.I.E.L.D., the Avengers, and the entirety of the MCU.

The action scenes are tightly shot and fluid.  Captain America is finally given the chance to prove his dynamism in “Captain America: The Winter Soldier.”  He is agile and more gymnastic than he has ever been— Obviously refining his skills and training in order to adapt to Norse Gods, men in Iron suits, and, well…Hulk, along with a new world paradigm.  Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson), who stands by Cap throughout the narrative, is just as fluid and badass as she has been in the prior Marvel films.  This time around we get to see Natasha more in the raw— A little bit of backstory and vulnerability are exposed along with a dash of flirtatiousness thrown in for good measure.  Nick Fury remains stoic and secretive as always, but his role within the MCU also is called into question similarly to that of Captain America’s place.

09The cinematography and art style is at its best in this film.  Not only does Marvel Studios manage to keep an atmospheric cohesion between two films set seventy-years apart, they also manage to tie the two plot lines to one of Caps greatest villains as well as the massive juggernaut of “The Avengers.” This is an incredible filmmaking feat and a tricky endeavor on multiple fronts— “Finesse” is the word that comes to mind.  Continuity is tricky, especially when dealing with comics and an expanded film universe that now encompasses nine films and counting, but like aforementioned “Captain America: Winter Soldier” is merely a new puzzle piece being revealed to audiences.  It fits perfectly in the overall scope of things, and doesn’t deviant anyway from the big picture.

The acting is superb in “Captain America: Winter Soldier.”  Chris Evans is excellent as always and is a more believable Captain America than he ever was a Johnny Storm.  Scarlett Johansson’s Black Widow seems to improve every time she stars in a new Marvel film, and the vulnerability and rawness that Johansson brings to the character was particularly believable and refreshing.  It is honestly coming to the point where she could probably handle her own, standalone “Black Widow” film and Marvel would see the return that they would need to film another.  Anthony Mackie is a standout actor that brings a certain modernity to his role as Falcon and ultimately one of Captain America’s closest friends.  The Winter Soldier was excellently cast and written; the presence, shock and awe, and gravitas that Sebastian Stan brings is impressive.  Villains have always been a comics mainstay, and (as Loki has proven) can be incredibly popular and successful in their own right, and with further backstory and films the Winter Soldier can perhaps reach the lofty height of Hiddleston’s portrayal as Loki.  Watching Robert Redford on screen was fantastic.  He played Alexander Pierce wonderfully and his inclusion added another layer of sophistication that rounded out an already stellar cast and well-constructed plot.  Redford’s inclusion was very much akin to Tommy Lee Jones’ portrayal of Colonel Chester Phillips in “Captain America: The First Avenger.”

The film was impressive to say the least.  The plot line was impressive for its continuity and level of construction; the castings and overall acting were topnotch and more than a couple of decades ago would have been unheard of for a comic book film; the atmosphere, art direction, and cinematography managed to tie in numerous elements of prior films while remaining cohesive is the film’s high point among many highs.  At the moment, it is difficult to imagine a film franchise reaching such heights, except for maybe Star Wars.

Fan Art

As an aside, I had the pleasure of seeing two different showing of “Captain America: The Winter Soldier.”  One was opening evening (but was a standard theater showing), however the second viewing was an IMAX 3D one.  I usually don’t prefer IMAX 3D presentations due to issues with my contact lenses, but this time around I preferred the experience because it was more enveloping.  The IMAX presentation showed quite a bit more peripheral action in the extended sequences and the 3D was not harsh upon the eyes, actually translating quite well to the viewer.  It was visually stunning and added to an already great cinematic experience.

To cap off such a film, movies goers were shown a brief glimpse into the franchises with not one but two after the credit scenes, so make sure to check out the post-credits before leaving the theater.  The first scene gives audiences as glimpse into “The Avengers: Age of Ultron,” while the second is little more specific to Captain America.  Nevertheless, they’re both worth checking out, so if you plan on seeing “The Avengers 2” and/or “Captain America 3” stay seated till film stops rollin’.


“The Avengers”

“The Avengers” with Robert Downey, Jr., Chris Evans, Mark Ruffalo, Chris Hemsworth, Scarlett Johansson, Jeremy Renner, and Samuel Jackson


Marvel StudiosThe Avengers is by far the best superhero movie ever created.  It perfectly straddles the line between humor, sentiment, and action.  The humor hits home for all ages and easily elicits laughter from audiences.  There are a couple of really touching moments that act as a wonderful bridge from the superhuman to the human—humbling superheroes to relate to humanity.  There is a particularly poignant scene, about mid-film, that could easily draw tears if in a sad state of mind—so be forewarned.  And, then there are the action sequences; throughout the movie they just continually build until it climaxes excellently.  With so many supernatural characters floating around the CGI was immense, but the bleeding was nonexistent and transitions were seemless.


The acting in the Avengers is phenomenal!  There have been quite a few Marvel films, so the setup and the introduction of the characters was minimal but cohesive due to the prior films.  Chris Evans as Captain America is near perfect. He is level-headed and innocent, and always fighting for a higher cause.  Evans looks a little beefier than he did in Captain America: First Avenger, and truthfully it makes more sense. Captain America has always been fit and close cut—he is a super soldier after all.  Robert Downey, Jr. is really the only actor that could play Tony Stark/Iron Man at this point.  It’s exact, and Downey brings his own charm to an already charming character.  Plot details are already trickling out about Iron Man 3, so stayed tuned for Iron Man news as it becomes available here on the Examiner.  Chris Hemsworthplays the all-powerful Thor, and follows up his performance from his own film by portraying Thor more humbly than before; which makes sense considering that the purpose behind the first film’s story arc was to ground an arrogantThor.  Mark Ruffalo was the standout of the film and should have always been the Hulk.  I honestly hope that they make more Hulk films with Ruffalo as the lead.  He played Bruce Banner superbly, and the Hulk’s part in the movie was hilarious and it would have been tarnished without him.

Jeremy Renner as Hawkeye sits comfortably in the espionage, international assassin role.  Considering that his recent break into the mainstream has begun to typecast him into the spy role.  Scarlett Johansson as Black Widow, who I’ve always been ambiguous about, really stepped it up in notch in the Avengers.  Joss Whedon provided a bit more back story to her character and it translated well.  Hawkeyeand Black Widow bounce off of each other well and transform what would normally would be the weaker links of theAvengers into strong, well-rounded characters.  Sam JacksonClark Gregg, and Cobie Smulders round out the S.H.I.E.L.D team nicely.  Although I had an insanely difficult time not looking at Agent Maria Hill (Cobie Smulders) as Robin Scherbatsky from How I Met Your Mother.

All-in-all, the Avengers is the Ocean’s of superhero movies, and lives up to the potential in almost every way possible.

Directing and Cinematography

The directing is excellent, and I wouldn’t be surprised if theAvengers becomes classified as Whedon’s Magnum Opus.  He managed to blend the best-of-the-best from all of the leading up Marvel films into one great movie.  The Avengershas been one of the most hyped and highly publicized movies in recent years and it easily could have bungled, but Whedonpulled out all of the stops and created his best piece of work, yet.  The shots are tight and never stagnate.  Whedon is a hero to fanboys everywhere—and, he already was.


The plot manages to assemble a team together relatively easily and quickly, and seque into the core plot with ease.  I was hesitant about Loki being the villain, but it built off the plot of Thor and worked as a great introductory story arc worthy for the Avengers to battle.  The dialogue fit the well-established characters to a ‘T,’ and one of the key aspects of the film that set it a step above the rest of the Marvel lineup was the humor.  The whole film was sprinkled with it, and pretty much every scene involving the Hulk was hilarious.  And, as always Marvel left viewers with a couple of ‘after-the-credit’ snippets to entice audiences further.  There are two additional scenes, so you might have to go back for a second viewing, or YouTube clip to get the full experience.


All summed up, the Avengers is the best superhero movie ever created.  With an opening weekend of over $200 million the fans have already spoken and launched the Avengersinto a stratosphere of its own.  The acting, directing, cinematography, and writing all add together to make an amazing movie.  This is a must-see and easily receives a five-out-of-five star rating from this reviewer.